The Value of Video Review: A Guide to Player Self-Evaluation
By John Reddan, Technical Director | Madison 56ers Soccer Club

Self-evaluation is an important piece in being able to improve as a soccer player. Many times over the course of a season, coaches ask players to ‘take a look’ at themselves and ask questions about their performance, both in games and matches, in order to self-identify areas to improve.
It can be a challenge, to find the space between being too hard on oneself and not recognizing areas of need. Part of the challenge is that what a player remembers and what actually happened can be vastly different.
Enter the world of video review.
In the collegiate environment, we used video review regularly to evaluate / provide feedback to individuals, functional groups and the team as a whole. Going into a session, we told players ‘Remember, the video doesn’t lie’. This was our heads up that what they remember and interpret from a match may not, in fact, have been exactly what transpired.
We had a wing player who, for example, was adamant they were wide enough in the build out phase when we kept telling them they were not using all the space that was available. When we watched a recent game, well, there they were, ten yards inside the touchline. The impact was immediate, the player was much more aware of using the space.
But, that was a shared effort. Coaches watching, making notes, showing players and discussing. How / what to watch can be key, as not every youth payer is going to have the same eye for details as experienced coaches.
Below are key areas players should begin recognizing when watching video.
General Items to Note:
- Assess yourself AND the team.
- Assess the area / position you play, not just when you are on the field.
- Note capabilities of your opponent, we can learn from them as well.
Questions for yourself:
Do I keep possession?
- If not why not?
- Is it due to poor first touch, that is when receiving does the ball get too far away from me for the opponent to steal?
- Is the ball caught under me or does it take me in a direction away from pressure?
- Are my passes accurate? The proper pace - too hard? Too soft?
- Am I in a position to receive the ball that maximizes time and space? If not, what might I have done differently to improve the moment? Move earlier? Faster? Closer to the ball? Further away / into more space?
- Am I on my toes, feet moving, body balanced in preparation?
- Do I take chances in the right moments? Attacking third is where creativity and individual skill are most required. Defensive third is for less risk.
- Do I recognize moments for combination play to attack / build out?
- Do I recognize moments to shoot?
- Do I recognize when to take space / penetrate on the dribble?
- Do I recognize penetrative passes or do I mostly go backward / sideways?
- What is my movement like off the ball?
- Do I recognize when / where to move even though the ball is perhaps on the other side of the field?
- What is my body position like when I receive a pass? Can I see the field or am I closed off?
- Do I have good footwork / stay balanced / in a ready position?
- Am I patient or do I lunge / reach?
- Do I tackle with balance and purpose or does the opponent run through me?
- Am I getting physical contact / using my shoulder when side on?
- On approach, do I come at an angle to force the attacker into help?
- As a second defender, am I too close? Too far away?
- As a balancing defender, am I connected to my team or leaving space vulnerable?
Watching the Team:
- Shape in and out of possession.
- Accomplishing goals set in training?
- What is the opponent doing to be successful against us?
- What might we need to do tactically to be more successful - with and without the ball?
- Do we recognize moments to switch the point of attack?
- Do we recognize when to press v when to pull back?
- Are we on task even late in a half or beginning to lose purpose?
- Do we recognize when we need to play long to relieve pressure or do we insist on short passes?
Recent Posts







